CallForMe

How to Find a Good Contractor: Questions to Ask First

A checklist for finding a good contractor: where to look, questions to ask, what a written estimate and contract should include, and red flags.

By the CallForMe editorial team

Published November 12, 2026

Short answer: shortlist three to five contractors, check that each is licensed and insured, ask all of them the same questions in writing, compare written estimates line by line, and sign a written contract before any work starts. Never pay everything up front.

That's the whole method. Below is each step in detail, including the questions to ask a contractor and the warning signs the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) highlights.

Step 1: Build a shortlist

Good places to start:

  • People you trust. The FTC suggests asking people you know for referrals. Ask what the job was, whether it finished on time and on budget, and whether they'd hire the contractor again.
  • Map listings and review sites. Look for businesses near you with a steady number of reviews over time, not a burst of five-star reviews in one month. Read the negative reviews and how the business replied.
  • Trade associations and your local home builders association, which the FTC also mentions, together with checking for complaints with consumer protection officials.

Aim for three to five names. Fewer and you can't compare; more and you'll drown in quotes.

Step 2: Check license and insurance

The FTC's advice is to consider only contractors who are licensed and insured: confirm the license with your state or county, and ask for proof of insurance. Licensing rules depend on the trade and the place. For example, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics notes that most states require electricians to pass a test and be licensed, with requirements that vary by state.

Also search the company name together with words like "complaint", "review" or "scam", as the FTC suggests.

Step 3: Ask every contractor the same questions

This is where most people go wrong: they have a different conversation with each contractor and end up comparing apples with oranges. Use one list:

Questions to ask a contractor

  1. Can you give me a written estimate? What does it include, and what would cost extra?
  2. Are you licensed and insured? What is your license number?
  3. Who does the work? Your own team or subcontractors?
  4. Does the job need a permit, and who gets it? (The FTC lists a contractor asking you to get the permits as a warning sign.)
  5. When can you start, and how long will it take?
  6. How do you handle changes if we add or change something mid-job?
  7. What is the payment schedule? How much up front, and when is the rest due?
  8. Do you guarantee the work? For how long, and what does it cover?
  9. Can you give me references from similar jobs?

Asking in writing (email or a contact form) has a big advantage: the answers are recorded and easy to compare.

Step 4: Compare written estimates properly

The FTC says a written estimate should include a description of the work, the materials, the completion date and the price. Put the estimates side by side and check:

  • Is the scope the same? One contractor may have priced a smaller job.
  • Are materials specified (brand, grade, quantity) or vague?
  • Is the permit included?
  • Is clean-up and disposal included?
  • What does the payment schedule look like?

Don't automatically pick the lowest number. The FTC's advice is to ask for an explanation when estimates differ a lot: the low one may be missing something, or the high one may include work the others skipped.

Step 5: Get a written contract

Even if your state doesn't require one, get a written contract. According to the FTC, it should include:

  • the contractor's name, address, phone number and license number;
  • estimated start and completion dates;
  • any promises made verbally about the work and the cost of labour and materials;
  • a written statement of your right to cancel, if you signed at home or somewhere other than the contractor's permanent place of business;
  • no blank spaces.

Add the payment schedule, who handles permits and how changes will be agreed and priced.

Step 6: Pay in stages

  • Don't pay the full amount up front. The FTC notes that some states limit how much a contractor can ask for as a down payment, so check with your state or local consumer agency.
  • Tie payments to finished stages of work.
  • Don't make the final payment until the work is done and you're satisfied with it.
  • Avoid cash-only arrangements.

Red flags

The FTC lists these signs of a home improvement scam:

  • knocking on your door because they're "in the area" or have materials "left over from another job";
  • pressuring you to decide immediately;
  • asking you to pay everything up front, or accepting only cash;
  • asking you to get the building permits;
  • suggesting you borrow from a lender they know.

Add your own common-sense checks: no written estimate, no address, a license number that doesn't check out, or answers that change every time you ask.

A shortcut for steps 1 and 3

The slowest part is finding contractors and asking each one the same questions. CallForMe does that in writing: describe the job once, and it lists businesses near you from Google Maps (rating, reviews, phone, website, hours) and emails your questions to the ones that publish an address, with replies going to your inbox. For trades, see our pages for plumbers and electricians, and for moves, the questions to ask movers.

FAQ

How many quotes should I get?

Three is a common rule of thumb: enough to see a normal price range without spending weeks on it. For a big project, more can be worth it.

Is the cheapest contractor a bad idea?

Not always, but find out why it's cheaper. Compare what each estimate includes before deciding.

What if a contractor won't put anything in writing?

Treat it as a reason to choose someone else. A written estimate and contract protect both of you.

Get prices without making the calls

Describe the job once. We find businesses near you and ask them for price and availability in writing.

Start a free request

Sources

Explore more guides